Putting Stock in our Students
Finance seniors invest Cal Poly Corporation money in the stock market By Mary McNally
What would you say if you were told a 22-year-old college student would manage your retirement account or your investment portfolio? If you weren’t that enthusiastic, you would be underestimating a particular class of Cal Poly undergrads.
A select group of senior finance students in the Orfalea College of Business has been managing every investment decision for the Student Managed Portfolio Project (SMPP) since its inception in 1992.
Initiated by now-retired professor John Lindvall, the SMPP was initially funded with $200,000 from the Cal Poly Corporation to give advanced finance students hands-on training as fund managers and investment professionals.
The students have proven to have a keen understanding of the market: The SMPP has outperformed its benchmark, the S&P 500 index. The corporation has withdrawn investment earnings of $140,000. As of the last quarterly report, the trading account reflected a balance of $452,000.
And in 2007, sensing the stock market bubble was about to burst, the students recommended the entire portfolio be liquidated to cash. Professional advisors scoffed at their suggestion, but the students were vindicated when the overall stock market had dropped 40 percent by late 2008.
“This is an example of Cal Poly’s commitment to hands-on education,” said Ron Weaver, investment adviser for the Cal Poly Corporation. “Trading on paper is one thing. But when the risks are real, the pressure is different and the learning is tangible.”
The class is patterned after a real-world relationship between a client (the corporation) and its adviser (the SMPP students).
The students design an investment strategy and write a prospectus for the fund based on the client’s investment horizon, portfolio objectives and risk tolerance. For this client, the goal was to create a well-balanced, diversified portfolio to maximize growth and limit risk. To accomplish this, the class developed a strategy weighted heavily toward Exchange Traded Funds.
Class discussions, often led by visiting industry professionals such as long-term fund managers and college namesake and Kinko’s founder Paul Orfalea, include the effect of macro-economic factors, such as news in the world at large, and how that can impact the market.
“It’s one thing to manage money, it’s another to do it in the Great Recession,” Ramezani said. “The skills of learning to function in a crisis will carry over into anything they do in the future.”
Real Risk, Real Returns
Each year, the new crop of student fund managers assesses the legacy fund from the previous year’s group. Fall quarter is dedicated to conducting due diligence while developing a strategy for the coming year. Before assuming responsibility for the real-world portfolio, they work the portfolio on paper.
“The paper portfolios show spectacular success (with more than 300 percent annualized returns) and great failure (100 percent loss of initial capital),” Ramezani said. But failure, he added, is one of the great teachers.
“The risk has to be at the forefront of your mind,” said 2009-’10 SMPP student David Dudek. “The prior two years showed just how fast you can lose a large amount of money if you focus solely on maximizing returns.”
Through the course of the project, SMPP students learn to utilize the same techniques professionals use, including analyst reports and in-person interviews. They also master electronic information resources including Morningstar Direct, MergentOnline, Reuters and Bloomberg. By the end of the course, they can dissect the fair value of stocks based on Monte Carlo simulations, Sharpe ratios, and regression and dividend discount models.
“The last two years have been a once-in-century opportunity to see the world change in real time in a dizzying manner,” said SMPP supervisor and finance area Chairman Cyrus Ramezani.
The students managed the fund successfully while navigating the sub-prime credit crisis, failure of some of the nation’s largest financial firms, the health care debate, high unemployment, implementation of the federal stimulus package, and a surge in energy and commodity prices.
“The success of the program isn’t just reflected in the returns the portfolio generates,” Ramezani said, “it’s the confidence and experience the students gain from the experience.”
That translates to success beyond Cal Poly. In 2010, in the midst of one of the toughest job markets in history, Ramnezani said, every graduating SMPP student secured a professional position. Recent grads have gone on to jobs in the investment banking divisions of Wells Fargo, UBS and Citibank and in finance with companies including Apple, Symantec and Triage Consulting.
About Cal Poly
California Polytechnic State University is located in San Luis Obispo, Calif., and has an enrollment of 19,400. With its emphasis on agriculture, architecture, business, engineering, science and mathematics, and liberal arts, Cal Poly is one of the nation’s top producers of well-trained, work-ready professionals in scientific and technical fields.
About Cal Poly Corporation
Cal Poly Corporation is the non-profit auxiliary organization to Cal Poly, providing self-supporting, innovative, and high-quality services to the university and assisting the institution in achieving its educational mission. For additional information, visit www.calpolycorporation.org or call 805-756-1451.